A federal judge on Monday struck down President Trump’s January memo that had been used to limit new federal permitting and leasing for wind energy projects. The ruling comes as part of ongoing legal challenges from several states, including New York, and nonprofit groups advocating for renewable energy.
U.S. District Judge Patti Saris of Massachusetts ruled that the order, issued on Jan. 20, was “arbitrary and capricious” under administrative law, finding that federal agencies failed to provide a reasoned explanation for their actions. The memo had been particularly restrictive toward offshore wind projects, including some already approved or under construction, but also affected onshore projects that rely on federal approvals.
While the ruling removes a key legal barrier, the overall impact is uncertain because federal agencies have multiple overlapping orders and policies that continue to restrict renewable energy development. Advocates say the decision provides relief to communities and workers awaiting the economic and environmental benefits of wind projects, while critics argue that wind initiatives have received preferential treatment at the expense of other parts of the energy industry. The outcome of any potential appeals and how federal agencies proceed with project approvals in response will be closely watched.