Lawyers for Tyler Robinson, the 22-year-old accused of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk, are scheduled to appear in court on Thursday as they seek to further restrict media access in the high-profile case.
Utah County Judge Tony Graf is weighing the public’s right to follow the proceedings against Robinson’s attorneys’ concerns that extensive media coverage could compromise his right to a fair trial. Robinson’s defense team, along with the Utah County Sheriff’s Office, has requested a ban on cameras in the courtroom. Prosecutors have charged Robinson with aggravated murder for the September 10 shooting at Utah Valley University in Orem and plan to pursue the death penalty. Robinson is expected to appear in person on Thursday after previous appearances were conducted via video or audio feed from jail.
A coalition of local and national news organizations is pushing to maintain media access. Judge Graf has already taken steps to preserve Robinson’s presumption of innocence, acknowledging the “extraordinary” public attention the case has attracted. During a closed hearing on October 24, Graf addressed courtroom attire and security protocols, allowing Robinson to wear street clothes but requiring restraints for safety. The judge also barred media from photographing or filming him in restraints, citing concerns about potential prejudice to future jurors.
Media attorneys have argued that open court proceedings protect the integrity of the judicial process and foster public confidence. Current Utah courtroom rules already limit media access, typically allowing one photographer and one videographer, while additional journalists may observe and take notes. Erika Kirk, Charlie Kirk’s widow, has urged for full transparency, insisting cameras should be allowed in court.
Robinson’s defense highlighted the broad reach of pretrial publicity, including statements from former President Donald Trump asserting confidence in Robinson’s arrest and expressing support for the death penalty. Attorneys also raised concerns about digitally altered images of Robinson circulating online, showing false depictions of emotional outbursts that never occurred in court.